Why We Love It: Lube is a must-have if you’re having anal sex or using anal toys. Most lubes are safe to use anally, but the Wicked Jelle Water-Based Anal Lubricant is specially designed for anal play. This water-based personal lubricant has an extra-thick formula that provides a cooling, tingling sensation when it’s applied to your skin. It’s also designed to last longer than many other water-based lubes, so ideally you won’t have to reapply as frequently.